Musk Thistleand
Plumeless Thistle
Carduus nutansand
Carduus acanthoides
Introduction
The musk thistle and plumeless thistle were introduced to the
US from Europe and Asia. Musk thistle and plumeless thistle are very
difficult to tell apart. They were first discovered in Tennessee
in the 1940’s and have spread to many states since then. These two
thistles are biennials that form a rosette in the first year and in the
second year they send up a reproductive stalk from the rosette. This
stalk bears the flowers which can produce up to 120,000 wind dispersed
seeds per plant. In warmer climates the thistle can have an annual
life cycle, in other words, it will send up a stalk the same year it produces
the rosette.
Environmental Impacts
The musk and plumeless thistles are completely unpalatable to
grazing livestock. In overgrazed rangeland, they can completely take
over the forage that animals need. They spread very rapidly because
of the high amount of seeds produced per plant and because the seeds are
dispersed by the wind. Both weeds are noxious in Nebraska.
Remedial Action
There are many ways to control these thistles. They can
be controlled by mechanical, chemical, and biological means. Mechanically
controlling the musk and plumeless thistle is very labor intensive and
is probably only effective on small areas. Chemical control is the
most widely used control method for these thistles. Any chemical
that will control broadleaf weeds such as 2,4-D, and Tordon will control
musk and plumeless thistle and leave the native grasses unharmed.
There are some biological controls that work on the thistles. Two
weevils have been released that feed on these thistles but research has
indicated that they also feed on native thistle species.